Latest
3 min agoSmart-Bin Billing Dispute in Florence Area Heads to Italy’s Court of Auditors and ARERA 52 min agoSignify Adds Smart Faults To Interact To Correlate Outdoor Lighting Network Anomalies 55 min agoFamagusta District Authority Approves €17.7M For 2027 Flood, Sewerage And Smart Meter Projects 1h agoChiyoda City Installs 22 Forcetec SmaGO Solar Compacting Bins In Akihabara 2h agoItron Brings Grid Edge Intelligence To EMEA Utilities With Glitre Nett As Early Adopter 2h agoGo Eve Secures £750,000 From Innovate UK And Investors To Upgrade DockChain Fleet Charging 2h agoOnda Uses €150,000 Valencian Innovation Grant To Build Ondata Municipal Data Platform 2h agoVeolia Fits €10,000 Lixo Cameras To Loire-Atlantique Refuse Trucks To Audit Business Waste 2h agoHera Group Unveils NexMeter Pro Gas Meter And Plans 300,000 Units Between 2027 And 2029 2h agoPUB Trials Road Flood Sensors And Remote-Controlled Pump Vehicle In Singapore
Kurrantly News · Weekly briefingThe week in smart cities and utilities, in one email
Share
Waste · Italy

Smart-Bin Billing Dispute in Florence Area Heads to Italy’s Court of Auditors and ARERA

Committees from 16 Florence-area towns ask the Corte dei conti and ARERA to test Plures Alia Genius 5.0 smart bin volume readings used for Taric bills.

Kurrant News Desk · ·5 min read
Row of grey kerbside waste containers with blue, brown, green, yellow and white lids lined along a paved street in a European town

Citizens’ committees from 16 municipalities in the province of Florence have taken their dispute over sensor-based waste billing to two national authorities, filing an esposto with the Tuscany regional prosecutor of the Corte dei conti, Italy’s public audit court, on 4 November 2026 and a second complaint with the energy, networks and environment regulator ARERA on 6 November, over the Genius 5.0 volumetric containers that Tuscan multiutility Plures uses through its environmental services arm Plures Alia to calculate the variable part of household waste bills.

The filings come from the Unione dei Comitati “Taric sì ma non così”, joined by the Lastra a Signa committee Liberamente le Signe and the Valdisieve committee covering Pontassieve, Pelago and Rufina, and they ask both bodies to verify whether the litres recorded by the containers are reliable and lawful enough to set the Taric, the tariffa corrispettiva that charges households for the residual waste they produce rather than only for the floor area of their homes, according to La Nazione.

Five Municipalities Already Billed On Sensor-Estimated Litres

Lastra a Signa was the first municipality to move to the Taric, in January 2023, after Alia replaced 106 kerbside collection sites with 102 sites of digital containers, according to a May 2023 company release, and complaints about disputed bills of up to several thousand euros followed at the end of 2023.

Since January 2026 the Genius 5.0 system has also been used for billing in Signa, Pelago, Pontassieve and Rufina, with the three Valdisieve municipalities alone accounting for about 25,000 domestic and non-domestic users. In Florence itself the containers are already on the street but are not yet used to calculate volumes, because the corrispettiva tariff has not been activated there, according to Dai Colli Fiorentini.

How Genius 5.0 Turns A Point Cloud Into A Bill

Alia Multiutility and Nord Engineering, a smart waste equipment maker based in the province of Cuneo in Piedmont that reports 300,000 containers produced for 400 cities, presented Genius 5.0 in Florence on 23 November 2023. The container does not weigh waste: an internal volumetric sensor captures a point cloud, a proprietary cloud algorithm developed with the Mathematics Department of the University of Florence derives the volume deposited, and the system assigns it to the user who opened the hatch with the app or the A-pass key.

The two partners filed two patents, one for the sensor and one for the electronic board. During the Lastra a Signa pilot on 110 containers, the companies reported an average of 4.61 deposits per container per day, an average deposit of about 30 litres with 95% of deposits under 85 litres, and an average fill level of 46.15% at emptying.

“L’innovazione che presentiamo è il primo brevetto depositato da Alia Multiutility” (“The innovation we are presenting is the first patent filed by Alia Multiutility”), said Alberto Irace, chief executive of Alia Multiutility, in the company’s November 2023 press release.

Quarterly Thresholds That Make Each Litre Count

The bill combines a fixed part, based on floor area and the number of residents, with a variable part that compares sorted collections against residual waste. Each household starts from a minimum quarterly allowance of residual waste of 20 litres for one person, rising to 40, 60, 75 and 90 litres for households of two to five people and 100 litres above five, while organics, packaging and paper never add cost and glass is not counted, according to the information brochure Alia prepared for Signa residents.

Under the “maximum sorting” profile described in the brochure, households that sort less than 50% of their waste pay a surcharge on each deposit above the minimum and those reaching 80% receive a reward, with bills issued every three months and the count reset each quarter. Because the sensor reads volume rather than the number of openings, Alia advises residents to use small bags, which makes the litre attributed by the algorithm the unit on which the rest of the tariff is built: for a three-person household with a 60-litre allowance, a single 8-litre bag recorded as 48 litres would consume 80% of the quarterly threshold.

Five Anomalies Cited In The Filings

The committees attached a technical note on the two patents and field-test videos, describing readings that rise in tests repeated a few seconds apart even with no waste, volumes recorded when the hatch is opened empty or the key is only touched to the display, positive charges whether an item is inserted or removed, deposits billed to users who say they never made them, and estimates of up to six times the real volume deposited.

They ask the Corte dei conti prosecutor to assess whether a volume estimate can serve as a measurement under the ministerial decree of 20 April 2017, which sets the criteria for measuring waste under punctual tariffs, and they cite a 14 September 2026 note in which the Florence Chamber of Commerce said its technical checks were ongoing and that it had forwarded the documentation to the Ministry of Enterprises and Made in Italy, which oversees legal metrology, according to Clebs.

Plures Alia Says Quarterly Totals Absorb Single-Reading Errors

Plures Alia told La Nazione that the technology went through a testing and validation process with scientific support from the University of Florence, that checks are repeated at each software update alongside real-time monitoring, and that no measuring instrument is free of margins of imprecision. The company said deviations in individual readings tend to offset each other, so the quarterly total is the reference for billing, and that volumetric measurement accounts for only part of the amount charged.

A Multiutility Planning A Wider Rollout

Plures was formed on 26 January 2023, initially as Alia Multiutility, through the merger of Alia Servizi Ambientali, Publiservizi, Consiag and Acqua Toscana, and now serves more than two million users under a €2.5 billion five-year investment plan for 2025 to 2029, according to Forbes Italia. At its creation the group provided environmental services in 58 municipalities across the provinces of Florence, Prato and Pistoia, home to about 1.5 million people, and it has said publicly that Genius 5.0 containers will be installed progressively across the province of Florence.

The Chamber of Commerce review and the ministry’s position on legal metrology, read alongside any action by ARERA or the Corte dei conti prosecutor, will set the test for whether a point-cloud volume estimate qualifies as a billing measurement under the 2017 decree, and that test carries over directly to Florence, where the same containers are already installed and waiting for the corrispettiva tariff to be switched on.